Antibiotic Resistance, Food Safety and Human Illness, Lifestyle, Organic

Reply to National Resources Defense Council Article: “Nature’s Take on Antibiotic Resistance and Some Troubling Responses”

In a recent blog from the NDRC, I was called out and described as “industry aligned.” I was “flattered” that NRDC mentioned research on the quantifiable risk of on-farm antibiotic use.  I think the author meant to discredit me by calling me “industry aligned.” Maybe someone who has worked in agriculture for 30 years, 13 of those in the USDA, is untrustworthy as he claims.  Maybe someone who implemented the largest meat recall in US history, at the costly chagrin of the “industry,” does have the industry in their pocket book.  But perhaps he means that I care about those farmers and ranchers who care for my patients: the animals.  I will assume the latter and thank him for the compliment.

On the slightly more specific question of risk, there are many points which need to be made, as this is not a simple issue.  Many of those points can be found in my previous blog postings listed below. But first, let’s distinguish concern from risk. FDA has directed the question of risk be answered by looking at the “subset” of the food borne route (Guidance 152). They understand the other routes (water, manure, air, karma) are, at this point, hypothetical.  FDA has shown by their actions that addressing specific antibiotic use or misuse issues is better than broad bans against on-farm antibiotic use in general.

The flip side of antibiotic use in animals needs to be considered. As a veterinarian this is also my concern. Animals need medicine also. Whether they are raised indoors or outdoors, free range or confinement, natural and whatever is the opposite of “natural,” infectious disease is everywhere.  Failure to prevent and treat illness is an ethical breach.

Further Reading:

Hurd Health Blogs:

Is antibiotic free really healthier?
New Campaign, “Meat without Drugs” could be inhumane!

Huffington Post: Meet the Meat People

Meatingplace Magazine Blogs: The Gentle Vet (requires free membership)

Animals Need Medicine, Just Like Kids
Medicines for my mamas


One thought on “Reply to National Resources Defense Council Article: “Nature’s Take on Antibiotic Resistance and Some Troubling Responses”

  1. I know this website offers quality based posts
    and extra information, is there any other site which presents such things in quality?

    Posted by get more twitter followers now | February 20, 2014, 4:33 am

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Keep up with Hurd Health:

Expand2Web Twitter Feed

Expand2Web YouTube Link

Expand2Web Facebook Link

Expand2Web LinkedIn Profile

I hope you'll join the conversation with us!

Follow Hurd Health: Animal Health and Food Safety on

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 179 other followers

%d bloggers like this: